Documentary Business

Peter Hamilton Consultants, Inc

Peter Hamilton Consultants, Inc

True Crime Update: Ed Hersh’s Expert Takeaways

by Ed Hersh.

Caitlin Cooper’s comprehensive list of streaming commissions (April 10, 2025) spotlights key evidence of the evolution of True Crime documentaries.

While not being produced in bulk, as in the heyday of cable channels like A&E, Oxygen, and Investigation Discovery, True Crime is a critical component for streamers like Hulu, Netflix, Peacock, and Paramount+ because it has a built in, passionate fan base that always hungers for more content.

Streamers no longer have to fill the 24/7 schedule of a cable network; they can commission a limited doc series designed to create marketing buzz and attract a younger audience, always their goal!

But the seemingly diverse crime documentaries on Caitlin’s latest Documentary Business survey are actually bound together by just a few themes that I often talk about with my clients, Syracuse University students, and on industry panels:

Crime, Meet Pop Culture, then Sprinkle in Sex:

  • The enormous success of ID/Max’s “Quiet on Set,” and before that, Lifetime’s “Surviving R. Kelly” underscores how pop culture icons, whether a TV channel or a rapper, command a built-in audience.
  • This list contains murders of bloggers, vloggers, the bizarre cultural phenomena of Luigi Mangione and Gabby Petito, and other crimes (or suspected crimes) involving pop stars, including Matthew Perry, the “Rust” set shooting, Chris Brown, and the duo Tegan and Sara, often with the ingredient of sexual overtones.
  • “They market themselves,” one development executive told me.
  • Expect this trend to continue as these programs proliferate.

When in doubt, play the oldies!

  • New looks and new insights into historical crimes that captured the zeitgeist dominate this list, from Jon-Benet Ramsey to the “Beauty Queen Killer” to TWO documentaries about Scott and Laci Peterson to the Menendez Brothers to Charles Manson, and new ones are constantly being commissioned.
  • Why? These are well-known and notorious crimes, criminals, and mysteries that have become “brand names,” a constant source of questions and speculation which even after 20 or 30 years later continue to captivate the audience’s imagination.

Access is everything… along with the promise of something new

  • Despite all of this, the bar is higher than ever.
  • You simply CANNOT pitch a true crime story without being able to use the phrase, “never before seen/heard archive” or exclusive access to witnesses, investigators or participants who have not spoken before.
  • That access needs to be locked up before you even walk in the door to make your pitch.

And beyond these takeaways…. keep in mind:

  • Platforms continue to expand their definition of True Crime.
  • The new areas of growth go beyond murder mysteries into the expanding genre of “howdunits:” shocking scams, ingenious heists, terrifying cults and Wall Street fraud, often focusing on slow-motion trainwrecks like the Fyre Festival, the Theranos collapse, or abuse at Nickelodeon, all in service of a universal question: “How could this have happened, and how did they get away with it for so long?”

All of this said, and despite industry and trade upheaval, the true crime genre continues its incredible growth around the globe; understanding how the landscape has changed, what streamers and want and need, and adapting to new forms of storytelling are all critical to getting that greenlight.


About Ed Hersh

Ed Hersh is a veteran media executive, strategist, and senior consultant specializing in non-fiction and true crime.

Through StoryCentric (www.storycentric.com), the consultancy he founded, he provides insights on storytelling, development and pitching to networks and producers in the US, Canada and Europe.

Ed also consults on PBS initiatives about pressing social topics and is an adjunct faculty member at Syracuse University’s Newhouse School of Public Communications. He can be contacted at [email protected].


Caitlin’s Previous True Crime Roundups